Patrefans
athassprkr from patreon
athassprkr patreon

(Enchanting Melodies) Chapter 52: The Truth to Happiness

🕑 Added 2023-04-24 13:41:26 +0000 UTC

Comments

Shadowsmage

well, our POC of Slytherin is evil comes from Harry who we know in cannon is an unreliable narrator. We only know things if he was interested. If everyone in Gryffindor says 11-year-old Slytherins are evil, then that must be true. I agree its fun though. ALthough Ravenclaw has its own issues, which Harry disappointed me in that he never stepped up and helped Luna. Then again he never stood up for himself so it makes sense.

Astral Aion

That’s what I got out of it and it’s pretty much cannon people really didn’t care for magical creatures or those that studied them until newt came along sure they knew about them and had some understanding of them but it wouldn’t be more than a typical person’s understanding of a tiger or a polar bear i.e. vague and distant

Chris

I think everything in this fic is a good reason why if you were actually reincarnated you would not want to be in Slytherin. Harry should have pushed for ravenclaw but that would make for a less interesting plot.

Chris

I think what you were trying to say was that while magical creatures were studied the emphasis was on potions or wands. How wizards could use the animals where Newt pushed the idea that magical creatures should be preserved for their own sake.

athass_prkr

Well, this was mostly a small hint about something else, but I didn't say that wizards are idiots, at least I didn't really mean to put it that way. I just considered them to be selfish. They learn about magical creatures by looking at what they can harvest from them, how to fight them, and how to defend against them, but didn't really research their habits, rituals, or how they came to be, until Newt that it, who started an entire movement with his book. At least, that is simply what Harry could infer from his visits to the library, which isn't always correct. Honestly, the paragraphs about magical creatures are sort of a prelude about something, which is going to be critical in the second and third years. And believe me, the purpose of the arc won't be to show that 'Wizards are Dumb'.

Dull Pen

A lot of the world building in this story ends up being bashing, or mentioning it. The family crests were original and interesting... and say the things with the Unicorns as well. It is quite interesting we get a mention of them being more spirit for example. Those are the good parts! But we also get the almost cliche that wizards are so stupid, even with thousands of years of history nobody bothered to even slightly investigate magical creatures? Except Newt? Please, this is pure bashing. Not only does it not make any sense, it is contradicting both canon and this story. Given that magical beasts are one of the few things that can harm wizards and witches and they even created a rating system and laws regarding them, one would think people sure like to know about them. Even if the only reason they were investigated was human interest and greed for their parts (which is what most of human discoveries is based on, the rest being due to sexual desires and boredom), they would have known a lot about them, especially given that Unicorns are one of the few beings that are still used in wand creation. This isn't the first time the reason why we don't get more in depth description on something is "wizards are stupid and did not care", so we get the generic "sooo mysterious" description about something. That is not really a good take on things. Just a cop-out on why an author doesn't have to do world building for that specific thing. There is nothing wrong with depicting magic as mysterious, and not doing the scientific breakdown of it... but bashing everyone else in the story-world for not seeing something that was oh so obvious to the MC is just bad writing. For example, cloud9stories, and the fic "The Bigger Picture" has a pretty interesting take on magic, or say "A Degree in Sorcery" or "Odyssey of Magic". A lot of them are out there, which keep the mystery of the HP magic-verse, but also explore it and build rules around it, far better then the original ever did. In many cases it is via some form of animism and based on the power of belief. It works that way because it was done that way a thousand times before. "Magic Remembers" being the basis of it all. Though there are different depictions and interpretations, that is my preferred one.


More Creators