OnAHiatus
patreon
CHAPTER TEN - THE LONG-AWAITED CONFRONTATION
🕑 Added 2024-12-28 15:47:21 +0000 UTCThe rooftop was cold and silent, save for the distant wail of sirens and the hum of Gotham below, a patchwork of flickering lights and shadow. Taylor stood on the edge, her hood drawn tight against the biting wind, and clenched her fists, her thoughts going back to the warehouse raid with Robin. As much as they had gained, she couldn't shake the nagging feeling that they were falling behind—that they were playing catch-up in a game they barely understood.
She exhaled, her breath fogging in the air, and turned to move when a shadow fell over her.
“Swarm Queen.” The voice was deep, commanding, and impossible to mistake.
Taylor turned slowly, her pulse spiking as she came face-to-face with the Bat. He was everything she expected. Imposing; his towering frame was half-shrouded in his cape, and his white lenses reflected the faint moonlight—sharp and unyielding, locked onto hers.
“You’ve been busy,” he said, his tone unreadable but edged with disapproval.
Taylor straightened, refusing to flinch under his gaze. “Someone has to ensure those weapons didn’t flood the Narrows last week.”
Batman stepped closer, the subtle shift of his weight imperceptible to anyone but the most observant. His boots made no sound on the rooftop, even against the gritty surface, as if the darkness itself cushioned his steps. His cape flowed behind him like a second shadow, sweeping slightly with each calculated stride, always under control, never hindering him.
When he stopped, it was as if the air around him stilled. His stance was poised yet relaxed—balanced on the balls of his boots, ready to move at a moment’s notice. He didn’t waste motion; every turn of his head, every flick of his gloved hand was purposeful, designed to gather information or convey authority.
“Your actions are creating more problems than they’re solving. The gang war is escalating. Innocents are caught in the crossfire. And now we have mercenaries in Gotham, armed to the teeth.”
It wasn't just what he said; it was how he said it. His words didn't rise in anger, nor did they soften with empathy. Instead, they carried a cold certainty that left no room for doubt.
“Don’t pretend that’s my fault,” Taylor shot back, her voice rising despite herself, her heart racing, but she refused to back down. “You should even thank me. The weapons were already here. I’m just trying to stop them from being used. Or would you rather I sit back and do nothing while people die?”
Batman’s expression didn’t change, but there was a pause before he responded. “What you’re doing destabilizes an already precarious situation. You’re not coordinating with anyone. You’re reckless. You’re making this worse.”
Taylor felt a surge of anger. “Worse? Worse than what? The status quo? Gangs running the streets, people too scared to leave their homes? How’s that working out for you, Batman?” She gestured out toward the city. “You’ve been at this for years, and look at this place. It’s a war zone. Tell me how your precious order is helping anyone.”
Batman’s tone sharpened. “It’s not about me. It’s about keeping Gotham from falling apart completely. Every move I make is calculated to avoid tipping the scales too far in one direction.”
Taylor stepped closer, her anger boiling over. “The only calculated move you are making is maintaining control. But guess what? You’ve got this city running on fear, and it’s not enough. People are dying now. They need help now. And maybe I’m not as ‘perfect’ as you, but at least I’m doing something.”
Batman’s gaze softened, just slightly. “And how many lives are you risking to save one? How many more people are put in danger because you’re playing hero without understanding the consequences—without understanding how Gotham works?”
"You don't get it, do you? You can't save everyone by sticking to your rules. Sometimes you have to break them."
Batman’s jaw tightened. “You think you can do better?”
Her breath caught, but she refused to let the doubt show. “I think someone has to try. You talk about consequences like I don’t know what that means. But I’ve lived through consequences you can’t even imagine. I’ve lost everything trying to help people, and I’d do it again because it’s better than doing nothing.”
The silence between them stretched, charged with unspoken words. For a moment, Taylor thought she saw something in his expression—regret, maybe, or recognition.
“Your intentions are good,” Batman said finally, his voice quieter but no less firm. “But Gotham doesn’t need another vigilante making things harder. You want to help? Stay out of the way.”
Taylor stared at him, her hands clenched into fists. “I’ve spent too much time staying out of the way. If you won’t fight for this city the way it deserves, then I will. Whether you like it or not.”
Batman folded his arms across his chest. “If you keep this up, you’ll cross a line you can’t come back from. You’ve seen what Gotham does to people. Don’t let it break you.”
Taylor took a step back, She wanted to argue, to tell him he was wrong, but his words struck a nerve she didn’t want to acknowledge.
“I’m not your enemy,” she said, her voice softer now. “But I’m not stopping, either. Gotham needs more than fear. It needs hope.”
Batman didn’t reply immediately, but when he did, his voice carried an intensity that was impossible to ignore.
“Hope is a dangerous thing in this city.”
Then, without another word, he turned and disappeared into the shadows, leaving Taylor alone on the rooftop.
She stood there for a long time, her thoughts racing. His warning echoed in her mind, but so did her own convictions. Maybe he was right—maybe she didn’t understand Gotham as well as she thought. But she knew one thing for certain: doing nothing wasn’t an option.
Batman could question her methods all he wanted. She wasn’t going to stop.
Comments
Jack Max
Ah, makes sense. Taylor is, in retrospect, how civilians feel when they believe nothing has really changed. I know Batman means well and has done so much, but some Gotham citizens don't like it because, literally, the villains are STILL around and killing/hurting people. Taylor as such is what you get when a civilian thinks they can do better. And in some ways, Taylor DID help Brockton Bay... she just ignored the crappy stuff she did like allowing drugs or humiliating/hurting heroes because she's doing the good work. Both sides have their points.
OnAHiatus
Yeah, she is slowly becoming like how she was in Earth Bet
OnAHiatus
You are right. I forgot to add that, but eh, just chuck it up to Taylor being an unreliable narrator
Orion _1M
I feel like it's not expressed in the story, for example Taylor's coworkers talk about batman busting up one of scarecrow's plots, or a manhunt after riddler that appears in the local news, maybe PIG's laboretory gets busted by him or we get info about him fighting any other villain that he should be busy with. Stuff that shows us he's not just sitting on his ass because that's the vibe I got up to now, we got a little of this robin (Demian?) working with her, yet Batmen hasn't been mentioned actually doing crime fighting at all. Thanks for responding!
Disorder
How true, Batman not only spending his time in Gotham but helping the League protect the world from other dangerous threats. One of Taylor's issues is accepting things at face value, not considering why things are the way they are. This is what led to her making big mistakes during her attempts at being a hero, which only led to her hurting more people than she cared to admit. Taylor is falling into bad habits from Earth Bet, so I can only hope that her interactions with the heroes of Gotham will make her realize that her way isn't as good as she believes. Normally Taylor wouldn't listen to what others have to say, but with the Undersiders gone, their toxic influence on her is also gone. Friends they may have all been, but they had issues that led to poor decision making.
OnAHiatus
To be fair, Batman has a lot on his plate to deal with, but he isn't going to tell Taylor that
Orion _1M
Batman is acting just like the PRT did before everything spiraled out of control, trying to not rock the boat too much in fear of the situation getting crazy and a massive gang war in which way too many bystanders will get hurt while they lack the manpower to actually contain it and stop the gangs. The PRT had reason to fear the E88 taking over the city, they had about 24 capes more then the rest of all the heroes combined (wards and new wave). But what Taylor said was right, he is a cowered I thought he'd fight to his last breath to rid the city of the criminals and villains but he's just kind of "let them fight it out and the dying civilians well couldn't do anything", when he could have stopped these shipments, when he could have broken some bones. Maybe if Batman had better excuses like battling killer crock and scarecrow and others (villains that are way out of Taylor's league for now when she can't even use her power properly) I'd find his reason for not stopping the fighting and shipments more compelling but still And Taylor is used to killing, she should start killing criminals who go too far. Not common gangsters but if it seems like blackmask or the penguin get away she would have shot them. Taylor should have a gun on her at least, she's used one in the wards and while not having the ability to shoot perfectly like she had before (thanks to losing bug sense) it's still an important tool to be used as the last option.
Jack Max
Crap. Honestly, I see both as right but also stubborn. And just... dang it. Just a shame that they can't work together, bit won't due to different beliefs.
Disorder
That...didn't go as well as I thought. It wasn't terrible but it was no good as well. They aren't allies, which stems from different beliefs on how things should be done. Batman operates the way he does because a single mistake will lead to lives being lost and one death is too much for Batman. Taylor believes that so long as things get better, than she can accept the casualties her war on crime causes, though she does what she can to keep the body count low. Unfortunately for Taylor, her methods won't work because no matter how many times criminals are dealt with, the void is quickly filled by the machinations of new criminals. The methods she used to deal with crime in Brockton Bay aren't effective here.
