Knicker Knight
patreon
Tough Love Part 3 (Harry/Astoria Chapter)
🕑 Added 2025-09-19 06:07:39 +0000 UTC“Why is HE here?” Astoria Greengrass hissed.
She’d grabbed Daphne by the shoulder and pulled her sister over to whisper in her ear. Daphne looked annoyed at having been grabbed.
“Because I invited him,” Daphne said.
“WHY?” Astoria wailed.
Instead of giving a direct answer, Daphne smiled in an infuriating condescending way. “You’ll understand when you’re older.”
“I’m barely younger than you! And I don’t want to share a compartment with him!” Astoria yelled.
“Just sit down already. You’re making a scene,” Daphne said.
The sisters were on the Hogwarts express outside of one of the compartments. Inside that compartment, Harry Potter was sitting alone. Daphne went back in and he smiled at her. They sat down infuriatingly close to each other, basically rubbing hips. Astoria slowly came into the compartment and crossed her arms.
“I’m only sitting here because I already put my stuff down,” Astoria said. “Before I knew that HE would be here.”
She sat down on the opposite side of the compartment. Even though she was acting like this, Harry smiled at her.
The Hogwarts Express was bringing students back for winter break. Harry had been invited to stay with the Greengrasses by Daphne. Her parents were eager to earn favors from the most influential young wizard in the country. Daphne inviting Harry totally didn’t have anything to do with her new habit of sneaking out of the dungeons and going to the Astronomy Tower every night.
She would’ve had to fight Pansy for the right to bring Harry home if Pansy’s family didn’t hate Harry’s guts. So Pansy would have to live with not getting her world rocked for a few weeks while Daphne would get all the dick she could ever want.
The only one who wasn’t in on the plan was Astoria Greengrass. When she discovered it, she obviously hadn’t taken it well.
“You better stay out of my way,” Astoria said. “I don’t want anything to do with you.”
“I’m Daphne’s guest. We won’t bother you,” Harry said amicably.
“It’s a little bit strange that you’re talking like that, sister,” Daphne pointed out. “What’s wrong? Are you worried that you might be… tempted?”
Astoria blushed and crossed her arms, refusing to answer. Daphne laughed. To make matters worse, she stroked Harry’s arm.
Astoria watched her sister’s fingers slide over Harry’s muscular bicep.
They BETTER stay out of her way.
Otherwise, Astoria wasn’t sure what she might do…
LINE BREAK
One day later, Astoria had a pillow wrapped around her head. She was using both of her hands to squeeze it to her ears, trying to blot out the sounds that she was hearing. She’d already used a silencing charm on her room. Somehow, the absolute ANIMALS on the other side of the wall were being so loud that it wasn’t enough!
“FUCK ME! FUCK MY SLUTTY LITTLE HOLES! JUST LIKE THAT BABY! FUCK! FUCK! FUCK!”
“You sound like a street whore Daphne!” Astoria growled. “Aren’t you ashamed? Especially with some stupid Gryffindor?”
“FUUUUUUUUUUUCK!” Daphne screamed.
That scream was followed by a howl. Astoria could no longer take it. Rolling over fast enough that her nightie fluttered around her body, she grabbed her wand and used an even more powerful charm to silence her room.
It took her two tries to pull it off properly because it was advanced magic that was right on the border of what she could accomplish. Her sister's orgasmic screaming finally disappeared. Astoria sighed, laying on her back in bed.
“Finally,” Astoria said. “Some quiet.”
This was better. Who need to pay attention to Daphne over there, getting pinned and fucked by Harry’s muscular body? All those muscles straining as he folded Daphne like a pretzel. His dick—so big that rumors of it had even reached Astoria—would be pounding into Daphne’s pussy. Maybe he was even biting her tits. Astoria slowly touched one of her teats, almost identical to the ones her older sister sported, and squeezed her nipple. It would be like that, right? Astoria used her fingernails and did it harder, mimicking teeth.
“Fuck,” Astoria said.
Astoria froze. Suddenly, she grabbed her wand and canceled the spell that she just cast. Daphne’s screams and the thumps of her bed into the wall came back. Astoria shoved her fingers into her cunt and masturbated while pinching her breasts.
She came six times that night, each orgasm harder than any she could remember having before.
LINE BREAK
“Fuck fuck fuck fuck…” Astoria hissed.
It was her cussing this way this time, instead of her sister. Daphne was just moaning. Astoria running into Harry around the house was turning out not to be a problem just like he predicted. Because the two were shut up in Daphne’s room fucking nonstop at all hours of the day!
Their parents were fine with it. They were hoping that he would accidentally knock Daphne up and give the Greengrass family a politically powerful marriage.
Idiots. How could they not see that Daphne had taken a potion? With how long she and Harry had been at it, if she hadn’t, then she would already be pregnant. She was just willfully allowing herself to be a cocksleave for some stupid stud!
They were locked up in Daphne’s room, so Astoria was free to spend her free time however she wanted! It was just coincidental that the thing she wanted most was to put her ear to the shared wall between her and Daphne’s rooms and listen, catching every noise while touching herself and fantasizing.
“MMMmmmmmmm!” Astoria moaned.
Her pussy squirted on her fingers. Feeling the juices run down them, she breathed heavily. A scary realization was sinking in for her.
This wasn’t enough.
At first, masturbation satisfied her urges. With each passing orgasm, she got less pleasure, while her desires only got bigger and bigger.
She had to do something. She couldn’t do anything. But she had to! But she couldn’t!
“Damn it all!” Astoria said.
She picked up a pillow and threw it. The pillowcase had already been stained, like the rest of her blankets and sheets, with fluid from her pussy. The pillow hit the wall and slid down it. Astoria held her hand out, pussy fluid dripping from her fingers.
Whether this was a mistake or not, she couldn’t live this way. Damn Daphne for bringing this male temptress into her house!
Astoria couldn’t be blamed for what happened next. It was all biological, you see. Her pussy was begging to be filled. There was only so much that she could distract herself from that with calm and collected reasoning.
She had to do what she had to do. A plot developed inside of her head.
LINE BREAK
The windows Astoria had to operate in were miniscule. The only time that Daphne left the rooms was when she ate (at which point Harry would also leave) and when Daphne went to their shared bathroom. Astoria lay in wait like an ambushing predator.
The moment that Daphne went into the bathroom and closed the door the following night, Astoria pounced. She used her magic to seal off the room. Daphne realized something happened but she had left her wand in the room.
“Astoria? Astoria! Let me out!” Daphne said, pounding on the door.
“Shut up! This is your fault!” Astoria said.
She left her sister locked in the bathroom. Prowling down the hallway, Astoria was now wearing a loose silk robe that could be removed easily. She got to Daphne’s door.
Taking a deep breath, she opened it.
“That was fast,” Harry said.
The room was dark and reeked of sex. The air inside was hot from all the sweating and exertion that had gone on inside. Literally the moment Astoria walked in, the door closed behind her.
Harry had done it. He was on top of her in seconds. Naked and smeared in old fluids, Harry pinned Astoria to the wall. In the unlit room Astoria, who had grown into a body almost identical to her sister’s, could pass as Daphne. Without noticing anything was amiss, Harry put his tongue into her mouth and groped her shapely boobs.
He pulled her robe off with the hands that Astoria had been fantasizing about. Harry touched her pussy. Even though they were only fingers, these were a MAN’S fingers. Astoria started cumming as soon as he put his fingers in her.
Harry chuckled. “You sure got backed up after taking one little break. Keep cumming for me, baby.”
He turned Astoria around and fingered her from behind. He took his thumb and rubbed Astoria’s asshole at the same time.
Astoria wanted to demand, ‘How dare you touch me there?’ Instead of saying that, she just moaned. Her body felt strange. Harry was somehow able to touch her even better than she could touch herself. She didn’t know how that was possible!
Harry made her cum like it was effortless. When he took his hand off of her body, Astoria wanted to scream. No! Don’t stop!
He only backed off to move on to something better, though. When his hand was taken away from her, she felt his dick rub her between her cheeks. Astoria made tremulous noises from her throat.
She was soaked after Harry’s fingers got ahold of her. There was no need for more foreplay. His dick was shoved into her pussy and Astoria instantly became addicted.
“Fuck fuck FUCK! AHHH!” Astoria screamed, sounding exactly like Daphne had. “AHhHhHhHhHHH!”
Harry grabbed her shoulders in his powerful and manly paws. He held her so tightly that it felt like he was giving her a massage. Her big boobs were flattened against the door. This wasn’t how she expected it to go! They hadn’t even gotten to the bed! But Astoria wouldn’t change a single thing.
“Mmmm…” she moaned as her cheek was forcibly locked against the door. All that mattered was the way her pussy was getting pounded. All her frustrations that her fingers hadn’t been able to alleviate were being pounded away.
“You’re such a good girl…” Harry said. “Astoria!”
“Wh—What?” Astoria gasped. “No! I’m Daphne!”
Harry chuckled and didn’t let up in his pounding of her. “Did you think that I wouldn’t notice your voice changing? I guess Daphne is probably locked in the bathroom. I’ll have to get her out after this.”
“I— I— Astoria would never do that!” Astoria said.
“You can’t trick me,” Harry laughed. “You know that you’re playing into your sister’s hands, right?”
Astoria felt a foreboding emotion. Unfortunately for her, she wasn’t able to ponder what he said for very long, because his dick was making it impossible for her to think deeply.
“Wh-What do you mean?” Astoria asked.
“Daphne didn’t invite me here JUST to satisfy her desires,” Harry said. “She recently turned her life around by getting into better touch with her needs. It all goes back to the way I accidentally got her out of a shitty arranged marriage. Daphne actually cares a lot about you. She wants you to get as much out of life as she has.”
It couldn’t be… “You want to ruin my engagement with Draco!”
“I don’t care one way or another,” Harry said. “Although it would be a shame for a girl as pretty as you to end up with that kind of guy. Daphne’s the one who really cares. And honestly, Astoria, can you tell me that you could go back to him now?”
Harry’s dick was ramming Astoria’s womb and making her legs shake with every thrust. She couldn’t even count the orgasms she was experiencing. He was too big and way too perfect a lover. She didn’t answer his question because she couldn’t even bring herself to lie; Draco wouldn’t ever feel like a man to her now.
“Just fuck me…” Astoria said.
Knowing that she had given into the truth, Harry did what her sister wanted.
He moved his hands from Astoria’s shoulders down to her wrists. Grabbing them, he held her arms against her lower back and fucked her while her ass jiggled.
CLAP! CLAP! CLAP!
“How does that feel?” he asked. “Not too bad, right?”
“Mmm! Gahhhh! AHN! AHN! AHN!” Astoria screamed.
She was being as loud as Daphne had been. Astoria’s screams were so uncontained that Daphne could probably hear them inside the bathroom she had been locked in. For a second, Astoria derived pleasure from that. She quickly remembered that this had all been a plot to offer her up to Harry, making her satisfaction fade.
Daphne was probably smirking and patting herself on the back. And damn it, Astoria couldn’t even be mad at her! Because Harry felt too fucking good.
“FUCK ME!” Astoria screeched.
Harry thrust into her and released a torrent of cum. Astoria could feel it filling her… before she could even think about that, Harry had spun her around. He lifted one of her legs and fucked her against the door. He kissed her on the lips. With his dick inside her, full of his cum, Astoria could no longer pretend that this was just a biological necessity.
Her need for him went all the way down to her core. He was everything she could ever want. As she returned his passionate kiss, the corners of her lips turned into a smile.
All was right in her world.
As Harry fucked her in position after position, she never even considered the final piece of Daphne’s plan. An engagement wouldn’t necessarily fall apart after the bride spent one night with a man. There were ways to repair a hymen with magic and hide such things. Plus, Draco was desperate to get the next best thing since he couldn’t win Daphne over.
To free Astoria, they needed assurance. Like, for example, that Harry Potter bent her into a dozen positions and came inside of her in every single one. Unlike Daphne, Astoria had taken no special potions. Harry’s cum was already working inside of her, knocking her up.
By the time that she realized the ruse, it was already the next morning, and the “damage” had been done.
