Patrefans
Lurk from patreon
Lurk patreon

Dueling Hearts Ch. 23

🕑 Added 2023-12-29 13:27:55 +0000 UTC

Comments

Lurk

I'd like to see the reactions to the Bella situation after next week's chapter where there'll be a large amount of context added to it. Not saying it will change your minds or anything, but I'd still like to see how that one is received

Erinnyes

This one... this one didn't work. Too much of it feels like forced plot points that don't make sense so that drama can happen. Neville becoming Filch's assistant for example just doesn't really make sense to me. Wands can't "squeeze out" magic. They're focusing tools, not magical batteries of their own. Beyond feeling like it's depressing for its own sake, that just feels extremely shakey from a plot end. Similarly, the rules change makes no sense for... many reasons. If officially sanctioned duels for adults haven't lifted the restrictions "to make it more exciting", there's no chance at all that those restrictions would be lifted for large numbers of school children without massive backlash given the number and profile of participants. Doubly so, there's no chance that this could or would have been done in secret. Beyond simply that there's no way the Hogwarts staff member in charge of duelling could have been left out of such a change, we've seen repeatedly that the ministry is just absolutely incapable of keeping secrets even if it wants to. Bellatrix's suspension falls into the same category. Professional sports cheating allegations are extremely high profile, and proof of cheating is even more so. Just think about Lance Armstrong and his own doping scandal. That was international news for weeks and the shockwaves were felt through every other sport in the Western world. The league champion duelist doping would be massive news that would not and could not be kept secret. Your stories are truly awesome, and I hope I've left enough positive comments for you to know that I think you're massively skilled and I enjoy your content. This one though was not your best work.

Alkole

Please I feel bad for nevile change one line and let him come back 😢


More Creators