Patrefans
erraticerrata from patreon
erraticerrata patreon

Chapter 3

🕑 Added 2025-03-14 04:00:05 +0000 UTC

Comments

Nathan Fish

"Eating the sliver of god eased metaphysical friction s//between/ our bodies and the aether," "Over the last few days ships had docked bringing s/int/in/ not only entire crates of delicacies but also musicians and dancers." "By arriving near the end s/pf/of/ the process" "The western shore of the isle apparently bore a small but beautiful city with splendid beaches and lively evenings, which paired with s/promise/promised/ elbow rubbing with top Garrison officers was quite a tempting offer to some." "Children, you have been put to the test and not found wanting: you are s/now// are skopis now in truth,"

Victor Cavalcanti

There's no way the "eating a god will sharpen you" is just a minor buff to boons. There's lots of students that either don't have boons or are signifiers.

Chris O'Hare

I feel like there’s going to be a new horror revealed with these dead souls. Like, halfway through the next year they are told that each soul not bought in time turns into a or will claim another ten students at random.

BeautifulBusinessBoi

EE is on break until April 11th, per the AMA post. Payments are on pause for the month though!

LUXRUS

No chapter?

BeautifulBusinessBoi

Angharad finds Fortuna striking and is jealous of her whispering in Tristan’s ear? Her picker is still as bad as ever lmao

Skeys13

Marshall giving Cunt

Avid_Appletree

I wouldn't be suprised if the Masks do actually have a graduation ceremony but they have to find it first. Or maybe Tristan was just lying and the avtual graduation ceremony is infiltrating another graduation ceremony.

Avid_Appletree

It is very limited. So probably not that shocking.

Joseph

Or vice versa am enterprising skiritai could try to get weaker first years killed by tricking them into dangerous situations.

Pratyush Singh

Fighting Steel beasts is not training, not when it is meant to bring back a human life. In fact, this is the one time to actually use her contract - there are real stakes here, and purposefully limiting her skillset in order to improve would effectively be the same as putting her own improvement over the lives of the people she could save. Which, maybe she'll do, but at least based on her current characterization I do not believe she would sacrifice their lives for the sake of improvement.

Darryl Greensill

It doesn’t help anyone for first-years to know. Not the first-years themselves, their risk calibrations will be skewed in one or the other direction. And it doesn’t help the later years, because the first-years will pester them to please risk their lives to resurrect my love interest/sibling/kidnap target. I think the second-years will take the same approach as the attendants: try not to get emotionally attached to first-years.

Darryl Greensill

It’s a guild-based grind quest! But Angie is OPAF and will be kite-farming Steel mobs by the end of the book

Darryl Greensill

Thanks folks, lot of seawater been vomited up since then. EE, if you’re listening, a short reminder would be a good addition!

Jacob Burton-Edwards

On the one hand, Tristan is his gift that keeps on giving. On the other, why would he ever make anything easy for anyone?

Jacob Burton-Edwards

It's impossible to keep the first years unawares unless you completely prevent interactions between them. Which they can't, because there's only one Port Allazei which everyone needs to buy food from. Someone always talks. The only sensible thing I can figure is they just kept the first year in the dark to grease the wheels. Make sure there were people to bring back for all future students.

Dominic Corbin

Resurrected students fail and are sent away from Scholomance, so they aren't going to be telling many people

Jacob Burton-Edwards

Everyone believing in reincarnation probably reduces the shock value some, but I completely agree. It's wierd to introduce this in the third book.

Markos El-Far

I feel like that contradicts her clear character growth she has just obtained. Wasting a training opportunity to “cheat” would go against everything she learned on Ashpodel.

NuclearUmbrella

She used her contract in said duel, and Sarru found out iirc. She thinks she's cheating in the Acallar, hence Angharad's statement about learning her lesson from Asphodel.

Ed

well, one way to solve this it's to make a competition with the flint monsters, how many flints can you kill in a day? ten, fifty, one hundred. that way they learn their limits and help a little, a type of status competition. to choose the flint, iron, steel lists its like to choose what to fight, thousands of death bodies, a armed cult or a mountain-like god. its good that they can choose.

Noble Solana-Walkinshaw

Also people age out, it only keeps them a year and a day. So if for example they fail to make headway for six months, a bunch of the “backlog” of souls will clear out.

Draken09

I believe the first year students will be kept unaware. Their lesson is about the price of violence in blood. It's not until year 2 students learn to weigh the value of a life.

Draken09

And dislikes caffeine or anything psychoactive.

Draken09

Judging by the conditionals, the Acallar is... Holding them. Catching the souls that would have been released within its walls and essentially holding them ransom. Gods have been shown to hold games within their shrines. We saw many examples back in book 1. Now we've seen two more: Scholomance's devouring dare, and the Acallar's game of lives. Both gods exist here as they do because the Watch finds these games worthwhile to play, while the gods get enough to devour and grow. Scholomance grew too much and was belligerent before, but the Acallar seems much more willing to play its role. As Angharad noticed, the game is ultimately skewed in its favor.

Ed

It's quite fitting for the world they are living on.

Joe Rachman

Oh God what if Tristan is going to have to organise gambling as worship, he'd gonna hate it even if he made money as the house

John Harper

Is this the first time we've seen resurrection as a power? Feels like a pretty big deal. They seemed less shocked about that than I'd expect.

MouseThatJumps

I'd like to point out that between Angharad now being able to use her contract a few times each day, the Marshal implying that even steel list monsters can be solo'd, and the enormous Checkov's gun of beloved Skiritai comrades dying and needing to be resurrected, the stage has been set for Angharad to potentially slay several steel list monsters in a day. Is it believable now? No. But 80 chapters down the line it could be.

Jacob Shpiece

Annoyance at Angharad's reputation, with everyone cooing over 'the mirror dancer' - it sounds like the spite between them has only grown in the interim

Jacob Shpiece

This is so deeply fucked up. I didn't like it when I first read it. Resurrection always leaves a weird feeling in my mouth, and here we're talking about nameless characters who immediately walk off screen. The only thing I felt like it did was cheapen the accomplishment of those who survived to the end of the year. But thinking about the lesson this is going to instill in the Skiritai...teaching them to constantly measure the value of their own life, and death. Literally creating a marketplace in which their lives have a tangible value, and measuring the worth and price of each fight in terms of how many lives can be won or lost. Which is, as the Marshall points out, a pretty necessary lesson: in a world that is constantly looking to spend your life, this trains you to almost instinctively assign a value to your death, and to judge whether its worth the sacrifice. Which of course, has the effect of making the students measure every cause they'll undertake in terms of lives. It teaches them to use death as currency, whether their own or their allies, while also teaching them that their own lives (and deaths) are categorically more valuable than those from outside of the order. It is such a powerfully insidious lesson (really more of a dehumanization technique) to be taught.

Ash M

Wait, the author of Hope is a pale lights reader? Small world!

Poop McScoop

Is Shallini gonna get it? Also, contract breaking may not be the worst for Angharad.

sarvashaktimaan

Tristan is a mint drinker, let's go

Musclerelaxant

Subtle callback to Angharad eyeing up Fortuna in the finale of book 2 even in the midst of everything going down 👀

Sam Friend

No. It's 900 iron or thousands of flint. Which adds up better

Riven Refulgence

Tristan actually really liked the peppermint tea that Song served him in the past, so it's another touch that Song is looking after her cabal.

Ranger Science

I mean. It pretty much has to be something of a casino, no?

Pordgy

With how often he's involved with them I have to wonder if Tristian's original concept was inspired by the idiom 'Luck of the Devil'

Ryan Hearn

The duel in at the invite-only malani party which her uncle interupted, iirc

MAS

Respectfully asking that Fortuna’s shrine be completely outlandish and gauche.

Runaway_Cactuar

I love how everyone got fancy tea from Song except Tristan lol

Darryl Greensill

Anyone remember what Sarru’s beef with Angharad was?

Ed

so the math is like nine students back equal ninety iron or nine hundred flint, with half a hundred student killing monsters almost everyday i was expecting more.

Joseph

How will this work for the upcoming students when they are in their second year and know the seniors in their third year are killing for them so the pressure is less? If it only lasts 3 yrs it would work and force them to give their all by the end of the third year because by their fourth they will be able to save most and have little incentive for fights. And how well or will they keep it a secret from the incoming students with all the resurrections?

Lucy Severine

Oh that's incredible. Wow. Great chapter

Audrey Johnson

Ooh this Skiritai revelation is certainly about to stir up some ramifications of what honor means.

Joe Rachman

Also Tristan meeting Asher to ask for a shrine. This promises to be interesting...

Joe Rachman

Well the Skiritai are revealing themselves to be spectacularly fucked up...

joie01

it really just hit me. theyre seniors. theres first year juniors coming in. thats exciting

Joseph

Lucifer is terrifying for being able to build such a place. And the way it seems the narrative doesn’t see him as a god or the darkness but a formidable individual makes him more awe inspiring.

Pteromys Momonga

Well, that's an interesting surprise! I wonder if the effects of the Acallar are related to the Scholomance god, or if it's derived from a ritual or something. The Marshal described it as a temple, which would seem to suggest some divine connection. Certainly grim stuff regarding the costs and limitations of reviving fallen Skiritai, and consistent with the rest of what they've been taught. I really hope we get to read about the other graduation ceremonies when EE returns from break - especially the masked ball; I have a weakness for those.

Morgwath

Thanks for the chapter.


More Creators