Patrefans
dryskies_btb from patreon
dryskies_btb patreon

Update Going Forward

🕑 Added 2025-06-27 15:57:05 +0000 UTC

Comments

QuantumServer

Same sentiment as the group, though personally I prefer the fantasy setting and think that and ASOIAF would be lovely together, if any one from 40k would fit it would be Caine or maybe the Lion.

bleachballed

I'd say yes, most of the time, but not necessarily ALL of the time. Sword fights (any fights, really) can get messy and unlucky like that. It's not that Westerosi Knights are inherently worse in skill and training; it's that they don't have the same level of opponents to hone themselves against. Ciaphas IS a legendary swordsman. But you have to remember that he didn't win that fight. Jurgen did. With a meltagun. Ciaphas just held his own (exaggerated or not with the unreliable-ness of his narration) long enough to not die. So while I'd say he definitely outclasses the vast majority of Westeros in skill and experience, some of the skill caps for Westeros can get pretty up there, too (I'm talking about the TRUE exceptions for that, though, like Robert Baratheon, Arthur Dayne, Criston Cole, and Cregan Stark). Westeros lives and breathes martial skill. They don't face the same challenges as Ciaphas is used to, but they absolutely have the right culture of dedication and training that COULD have them standing equally against him. Not likely and certainly not everyone, but Ciaphas might find himself evenly matched by a few of the locals. All that said (rambled, I got carried away with this reply... lol), that's why I didn't want to throw Ciaphas right into a Westerosi war. It's just... not much of a challenge or harrowing experience for someone from 40k, especially Ciaphas Cain. Playing into social/political conflicts and the inevitable misunderstandings that grow Ciaphas's legend is much more interesting to me.

GoT779

It sound interesting, small note Cain would absolutely outclass all of asoiaf’s knights that guy dueled space marine a space marine if I recall.


More Creators