Patrefans
BarCalak from patreon
BarCalak patreon

12th Move: Rocket Fuel

🕑 Added 2024-09-12 03:50:32 +0000 UTC

Comments

Zerak

Basically this, not everyone cares about it, but some of us will stop reading and look up the origin of something to see if it fits if it feels out of place.

Bar Calak

All great feedback to take into account for the next chap!

David Karlsson

The origin of sayings is pretty apt. I Hate that kind of thing in Game of Thrones stories. It takes you out of any immersion right away

Zerak

Just noticed the first word of my comment is “dealt” no idea what that is. I think I meant really like the story. The story is good, nice concepts, but the 2 main issues I see is your trying to force in as many puns as you can (between character names and Pokémon names (or moves) that it detracts from the quality of the story. The other issue is that you are trying to meta game too much, well not too much, it’s bordering between really good and try hard. I think focusing a bit more on investing moves and other things that anyone could do if they had the mind for it is better than trying to make add unique stuff at every turn. Actually I think I presented it wrong, what I mean is you tried to fit too many events into a single action. You wanted to gain a new pokemon to the team, introduce a new mechanic (or how it works in your world), introduce team rocket, introduce how criminal elements recruit fall guys, introduce the alpha variants and pokemon surges. And get his crab pokemon to shine. I am probably missing a thing or 2, but the point is that while it’s good to have a lot of things that draw the attention if you have too many crammed to get her it detracts from each one that it lowers the relevance of it. I think the plot thread would have been better if you did not include team rocket in it. For the whole puns and pay on words I would drop it completely unless it feels like it would seamlessly fit into a scenario, or if he wants to censor his words by using Pokémon as euphemisms (not too often though). The thing to keep in mind is from a readers perspective does all that stuff add to the experience by enhancing the scene (since the scene is more important than the pun) or does it distract away from it. The other thing to take into account then (and this won’t really apply to most people as they don’t care about it) is how origin of a phrase, and would it exist in the Pokémon world, and would it be interchangeable with a pokemon name/move. This is not relevant unless the puns are a main factor in the story, or you make it a plot point that the MC uses phrases people never heard before.

Bar Calak

Good note. If it feels forced, it feels forced. Definitely will try to keep it more natural going forward thanks

Zerak

Dealt like the story, but you’re trying too hard with changing the sayings from our world to include Pokémon names. Some of it came off as censoring the actual word (which was sometimes actually good), and other times it just felt forced like the Tentacool. Feels too forced. It’s fine from time to time but if you keep trying to insert them you would need to actually put more thought into them which probably isn’t worth it for a pun. Or rather word change.

Bar Calak

If ursaluna wasn't gonna be an eventual Evo on the team I'd agree haha

Evertime

Man I kinda feel bad for sandshrew, big ol boss gets captured out of nowhere and wakes up in a foreign country. An alpha sandslash wouldn't be too bad of a team member yknow. Hopefully new mon is a willing and colorful character


More Creators