Patrefans
Kuzunalis from patreon
Kuzunalis patreon

FLTL Ch. 157. Reunited

🕑 Added 2025-01-21 14:30:01 +0000 UTC

Comments

Secret Weapons

I don't think RR is that bad... as long as you are upfront about what your story is. Stuff thats labelled as progression which meanders and wallows about trying to hold the MC back with idiot ball writing, yeah it gets slaughtered, but if you're upfront about your story being slower paced, slice of life, kingdom building, I think there's a place for that. I've seen a few successful kingdom building stories on RR especially.

Kuzunalis

Thank you Garran for writing such a detailed review. I'm glad to know that you have been enjoying it. I'll keep these points in mind in the future and I'll continue trying to improve my writing so you can enjoy it even more. And thank you for your support as well!

Hilly

Oh and I would also like to point out that RR has a community with a rather limited comfort-zone (no-harem, litrpg, fast paced progression) when it comes to novels and anything falling outside of that comfort-zone tends to get downvoted to hell. I’ve only been on RR for a year now so if anyone would like to correct me on this feel free. SH is a bit more open for other things (harem, smut, romance, alternative writing styles.) I believe you are already on there. WN is pure harem focused action xanxia/wuxia/murim and anime tropes basically… not sure if you’d find a fanbase there. Just be careful of their contracts, I’ve read horror stories about them.

Hilly

Well, I just finished binge-reading the whole novel over the last week, and I really enjoyed it. So thanks for writing FLTL Author. I would however like to give some feedback and also why I think you might be getting some of the bad ratings on RR. Prepare for a text-wall! #1: The click-bait adds! I first found FLTL by clicking on one of your adds on RR, the one with the cute girl bathing in the river. I though this was going to be an isekai kingdom builder with a harem/romantic subplot. Yet this story is one big sausage-fest with zero romance. The only female character of interest is Maisy, who is without a doubt the star of this story! But being a 10 year old kid she is an absolute no-go for romance. So yeah, I can imagine some guys clicking your add, reading the synopsis, seeing your tags and then giving you a 1-star review for baiting them. I on the other hand decided to give your story a fair chance which brings me to point two. #2: Research, I’m not sure if you planned the whole seasoned wood thing or if you really didn’t know. But Kivumus definitely should have known what seasoning wood means as an engineering graduate and a person from earth, wood seasoning/drying is pretty common knowledge after all. I learned about it when I was a kid and many more times while in high-school. You managed to fix that pretty decently though, so kudos for that. Yet still, I can’t help but wonder if you could have solved it in a more fantasy like manner. Such as claiming that fedarus trees don’t have to be seasoned because they only hold moisture in the bark or something like that. That is of course assuming you didn’t plan all of it, which you might have. The second fault I could find was the lack of tool-variety. Carpenters and blacksmiths use a lot more tools than just saws, axes and hammers. And while you don’t have to go into details about each tool, a short mention (and how many more they need) would have been enough to add realism. The third fault I could find was when you stated that they would make wooden roof shingles from planks. In the middle ages they would only consider making roof shingles from planks when there were more than enough planks available and they were cheap (so if they had a sawmill.) And even than they would still mostly make them from the heartwood parts of logs by hand, using a froe/axe and wooden mallet. Mostly because shingles made like that last 20-30 years while those made from planks only last 10 years or so unless treated with preservative agents. In case of this novel it would take a lot more time to make planks first and then cut them into shingles, than to just straight up cleave them from wooden logs. Especially since they could also use the sapwood part of the log as well since the shingles don’t have to last more than a couple of years. I noticed you also changed the whole wooden shingles idea to vertical placed wooden planks as a roof, which is arguably a better solution under the circumstances. My point is though, that it feels like you only did basic research, rather than a more in-depth dive into the intricacies of medieval crafting. But for such a detailed story which follows a more historical accurate narrative, good research is a must. The alternative would be a more fantasy like solution, like wood-magic or something. I nearly considered dropping the story when I read that line about roof shingles. And yes I know this is a fantasy, which is why I overlooked quite a few unrealistic deadlines and smaller details. (Seriously, 5 axes a day, who is this guy, Hephaestus reborn?) I highly recommend you watch some informative YouTube videos about medieval roofing, carpentry and blacksmithing as google and Wikipedia tend to be lacking when it comes to these things. #3: Pacing, or to be more precise the excessive planning and speculating. Often times it feels like I’m reading things twice because you have your characters plan things in detail first, and then have them execute those plans in great detail (though often with some variation as nothing ever truly goes as planned.) The best comparison I can make is like going to a movie after your over-enthusiastic friend already spoiled all the mayor plot lines. It’s just not the same as going in only knowing the basic outline of the story and it ruins a lot of the suspense. Most authors only give a small summary when they have their characters make plans, and then they go into greater details as things unfold. For example, the planning of the quarry rescue could have been summarized as: After hearing the heart-felled plea from Calubo, Rivamus decided to send his guards on a rescue mission. After spending some time planning with the others he went to bed feeling he made the right decision. Then the next chapter would start with some more details from let’s say Calubo’s perpective: Calubo couldn’t be more happy, the baron had send eight men and horses with him to kill the bandits and rescue the slaves, including Hyola…. That’s basically one of your chapter’s summarized. The thing is though, I don’t recommend you change your writing style to this more common and compressed way. Mostly because anyone who is still reading this story past chapter 50 actually enjoys your over detailed, slow paced style. So changing that now would probably cause you to lose a large portion of your fan-base, including me. I would recommend trimming down a bit on the planning and speculating, letting some of the details come forward as the events unfold instead. But other than that, your unique way of writing makes you stick out. As long as you’re happy with the response you’re getting, including the financial aspect, it’s probably best not to make drastic changes. You can always experiment with a new novel since you definitely have the talent and drive for writing!


More Creators