companyman
patreon
Thumbnail Poll - Need Everyone's Help
🕑 Added 2019-07-23 16:26:49 +0000 UTCSo here's the deal everyone: tomorrow I have a video coming out about Frito-Lay and how big they are and I've been spending way too much time on the thumbnail. I'm at the point where they're all blending together and I can't tell what's good anymore, that's where you come in. I'm up to 5 passable options and I need you to decide which is the best. So everyone please vote for your favorite and I'll be paying attention to any additional feedback. I'd really appreciate the help. All the options are attached.
Comments
Jim Smith
Another vote for #2. And I also don't think the backgrounds for 4 & 5 work as small thumbnails. If they were wallpaper, that would be different.
Company Man
Looks likes 2 is going to be the winner. I had to look up the word garish and I agree.
Shawna Lee
I also voted 2, I thought 4 was okay, but 3 was garish, that was way too much yellow.
Company Man
I'm thinking you're right.
Chris Lion-Transler
Two. Definitely #2. The last two are way too busy for a thumbnail.
Company Man
I agree with you about all the yellow. I hate to turn down an opportunity to use a bright, eye catching, yellow background but I also have to use the bag in it. Maybe I'm being greedy trying for both since it just doesn't seem to work. I guess the last 2 do look pretty busy, I just kept adding more things to shake things up but maybe I ended up with too much without realizing it.
The yellow bag on yellow background seems like too much and the last one seems so busy. Still like #2 the best, clean and simple with the logo everyone knows.
