Patrefans
alexwoolfson from patreon
alexwoolfson patreon

Double Cross Scene Compilation - CH2 Pgs 26-38

🕑 Added 2024-10-19 01:21:25 +0000 UTC
Double Cross Scene Compilation - CH2 Pgs 26-38

Comments

Adam Irving

I do think a simple reference in the appendices would be enough, especially if you use headers to mirror how the main storyline is organized. Once people realize how you have them structured - a key image as reference is a great idea - then it's easy to follow.

Alex Woolfson

Thank you for the suggestion, camelotcrusade. I can't seem to see that section in the Look Inside on the Amazon page, but I wonder if it is similar to the Making Of section I created at the end of the printed Artifice graphic novel...

Alex Woolfson

Thank you, Adam! Yes, my goal was to make Teen Spooky funny, but that his humor wouldn't be quite as sophisticated as his older self. Glad that worked for you. You make a very good point about the action being in a claustrophobic location, and how that changes things up. I'm often going for "epic" with my superhero battles, so I typically picture them in grand spaces, but I agree, it does up the tension to be in a more confined space. And I'm all for adding bonus material to the printed books. In fact, that's my preferenceβ€”to give that little bit extra to make them special. I'm just not 100% sure how to format such an appendix so that it's clear what I'm referring to and easy to make the connections. I could just reference it by scene using headers and include a key image like I do with the posts here. Do you think that would be enough?

Adam Irving

This was a fun scene, for all the reasons you stipulate. The humor bits do come through and don't seem forced or unusual in a way that would take the reader out of the moment. They are light levity rather than meant for huge laughs, in other words, and I think that fits. Spooky's quips are quite good and I like how the ones you have his teen version using are - while still good - perhaps not quite as sophisticated or experienced as his later self might use. Humor matures too. I get it about the unintended rhyme at the end. Just a personal preference but it feels like "boy in blue" would be the easier one to change. I like this scene in particular because of the scope of the action. We've seen some hellaciously large battles in some incredible scenery, but it's nice to have something tense and actually dangerous for our heroes in a pretty tight, contained space. Anyone feeling claustrophobic with baddies and bad magic all of a sudden? Finally, taking up some of the hardcover/omnibus-including-commentary, I get the challenges of translating something like this into actual print. But I DO like the concept of editing these up a little and tucking them in a set of appendices or something like that. Having them set in this way does not distract the reader when reading the story but also provides an easy access that you normally get with a Further Reading or Notes section seen in some books. Something worth exploring to see if they could be edited and formatted in some way to be both easy on the production team and rewarding to the reader.

Alex Woolfson

Thank you so much for that continuous support, Bill. It's really appreciated. I'm glad you're enjoying the re-read!

william clapie

I cannot believe how long I have supported your comic (in my own small way) ! Congrats on the longevity and thanks, the reviews/ re-reading are fun too.

camelotcrusade

Yeah, "too much" vs. "not enough" could be an issue with commentary. The pop-up idea is awesome, or maybe you get a "PDF companion" that essentially has your writeups from here that you can open up as you read the book. Something I really liked was how Colleen Doran did her commentary in this book, a graphic novel adaptation of Chivalry by Neil Gaiman. You can check it out here: https://www.amazon.com/Neil-Gaimans-Chivalry-Gaiman/dp/1506719112 I absolutely adore that adaptation, so if you don't know the story (or if you do!) I recommend it πŸ’―. Anyway at the end she did about 10 pages of "making of" where she discussed the challenges, inspirations, and journey of making the work. She also included draft sketches. It definitely felt like gilding the lily to me!

Alex Woolfson

I'm glad you found this a treat. And I like your idea of including the commentary in some kind of collector's edition. I'm not sure how I'd set that up (include it at the end of each chapter? at the end of the book?), and it would certainly add a lot of pages, so it probably wouldn't be a good idea for an omnibus. But if there is enthusiasm for hard cover editions of the regular books, it would definitely make sense to include this. If I wanted to get really fancy, I could have little "pop-ups" of my comments overlayed over desaturated comic pages to really make things visually interesting. It would be a lot of work, but if I'm putting these notes at the end of the book, it would help make things clear and engaging. In terms of the rhyme, it's "stuck to my shoe... kill the boy in blue". Maybe I'm the only one who notices that, though. If so, I won't change it. And from henceforth, Diane Cannon it shall be! ;) Thank you for your good thoughts on all of this! Much appreciated!

camelotcrusade

You know Alex, if (when?!) you go to print, maybe you could make a collector's edition that includes your commentary. Whether that's feasible or not, it's a treat to have that experience right here. I didn't remember ANY of this (was I sick? on vacation?) so that made it doubly enjoyable to read today. ⭐ I liked crazy Diane Cannon (that's her name now, according to me) and how Flyboy is the "adult" here. As for the rhyme, which dialog are you referring to? Everything read great to me. πŸ€”


More Creators