Patrefans
Emberhare from patreon
Emberhare patreon

[Ghst] Chapter 30: Regret and Redemption

🕑 Added 2025-06-27 02:22:42 +0000 UTC

Comments

Emberhare

Hey Seb thank you so much for your thoughts! A lot of really good points, I'd be very keen to see how you find chapter 36 in particular, because you get a brief glimpse at Noelle's perspective, and the extent to which she's redeemed. Really appreciate the comment, and I hope you enjoy how the development is handled! It definitely won't be a neat knot that's tied up by the end of book 1

sebsebs

I don't know how to feel about Noelle's evidently incoming redemption arc. I honestly don't like her character and how she's been treated so far. It seems like Evantra's loved ones and lots of readers felt a lot of empathy for her and wanted to give her another chance and felt that Evantra was too cruel to her but I really disagree. To sum up her actions : she planted a tracker on Evantra and stalked her, after having talked to her 2 times. Already creepy and not really okay, but that could be forgiven and she could be given a second chance I guess. Then she endangered Evantra by following her in the sewers, where Evantra had to shield her from a Salamander's attack because she froze up. Then she left her to die. That's not a minor mistake we can gloss over. And then, while Evantra was at the hospital, Carmen decided, behind her back, to invite Noelle to live at Evantra's place ? Now that's just insane. It would cross major boundaries even if Noelle was just a stranger instead of "a stranger who planted a tracker on you stalked you and left you to die". And then everyone seems to blame Evantra for being heartless ?? The only reason why it didn't feel outrageous that Evantra agreed, is precisely because Evantra is jaded and traumatised and didn't expect anything from Noelle to begin with. I think a normal person would have actually crashed out at Carmen and REALLY hated Noelle. Sure, as a side-effect, it also means that Evantra kept Noelle at a remove but so what ? She doesn't owe her anything, does she ? It seems like something is going on in the background but 1. i don't see how it could redeem the situation, whatever it is 2. IF YOU DON'T TELL EVANTRA SHE CAN'T GUESS IT SO DON'T BLAME HER FOR ACTING THE WAY SHE DOES Anyway, rant over. Evantra is far from perfect and most of her decision making makes me wince but if there's one thing that I found reasonable and more than fair, incredibly lenient actuallt, it's how she treated Noelle. Wanted to get rid of my frustration now, so that I can enjoy her inevitable redemption and the rest of the story, but just because she's able to change and become a better person and "prove Carmen right/Evantra wrong" doesn't mean that the decision to grant her that second chance was sensible. A positive outcome doesn't mean the decision-making was sound. Thanks for the chapter, I still love the concept of that story. I'm sad to hear about Fearshaper, the concept also sounded cool and it was on my reading list (I hadn't realized you were the author). Hope you find more success with this one !

UnderwhelmingBird

I think there's a joke to be made here about Noelle not being 'fired' but I'm distracted by the bittersweet goodfeels. Mostly sweet, tho.


More Creators