Patrefans
Brellom from patreon
Brellom patreon

TWAB: Stand back! I'm June-ing out!

🕑 Added 2025-06-07 06:01:15 +0000 UTC

Comments

mike stone

I think you might have associated choice of subject material with pandering, in a way that isn't complete. It's definitely possible to pander by choosing and rejecting subjects based on the latest trends or 'ten things you absolutely have to include in genre X' lists. But you can also pander by doing whatever appeals to the loudest fringe of any kink. The spectrum runs between exploring the subject and ticking off boxes of a 'things that get positive feedback' checklist. As a first point, most real work happens in the middle of the spectrum, not at the ends. Exectations are the things people find accessible without having to decode what you're doing. A lot of Picasso's cubism was based on the way humans encode visual information -- people draw footballs with circles until they learn to see the actual curves of an eye -- but people look at his paintings and say, "I don't get it". The expected/unexpected ratio is just as much a part of the artistic process as light/dark and color balance. You create emphasis by using one as negative space for the other. As a second point, everything is a combination of several games. You don't see people going on about "you can't be original if you're using colors people have seen before." You can be completely unoriginal in terms of linework and palette and still have a unique style. You can pander shamelessly with choice of subject and still do something interesting with context and treatment. Focusing on anything away from mainstream interests naturally reduces the size of the market segment that likes the subject. That's basic long-tail theory. The other part of long-tail theory is that the narrowest slice that appeals to the largest number of people is tiny compared to the space outside it. Yeah, stuff that's focus-grouped to appeal to millions is formulaic crap. But an individual can make a living with an audience of 1000 willing to pay $5/month, or 5000 willing to pay $1/month. A quick check says Patreon sees about 100 million users per month, so an audience of 10,000 would be 0.001% of that. Give yourself permission to defer questions about pandering until your subscriptions hit 0.001% of Patreon's monthly total. That doesn't mean giving up the subjects that appeal to you. It means expanding the range of subjects you're willing to treat until you find the balance of income and time to work on your own interests that works for you. A separate, low-effort account of more mainstream work that you're allowed to advertise would probably be a big help.

Shawn Heatherly

Please take care of yourself.


More Creators