Patrefans
VoidHerald from patreon
VoidHerald patreon

New Story Choice II: Sword & Shield (Eastern Cultivation)

🕑 Added 2021-07-25 08:52:07 +0000 UTC

Comments

Alex Lindsay

Also I say go all in on the female POV and make them siblings sisters!

Alex Lindsay

I think that while many think that this is similar to other cultivation stories, the focus on town building and the foreign influences and drugs will make this unlike any other story. I just have a feeling Void Herald will take this where none of us are expecting and the result will be even more original than the other story. It seems I am in the minority here, but go with this one an surprise us all.!

crownfall

Alright guys, we have to clone Void Herald

crownfall

I want both of them so bad

Ervin Ughy

I trust you enough as an author, that I'm sure if this one was chosen, you could make it into an amazing story. That being said, for the exact same reason, I sooo want to see your take on Underland. Those concepts are rarely explored, and you have a very unique style besides. It would be your next masterpiece, I'm certain of it.

Finn Ryan

Not exactly xianxia, but one I would suggest if you like the opium wars is the Poppy Wars

Nate

I'll vote for this one again but I doubt it'll win.... again. Cultivation but opium wars is such a great premise, damnit!

Xtriver

I like the concept of this better, but the introduction put me off. I do not know but it felt like a jumble of cliches. Like it was done on purpose, something like that.

Kyle J Smith

Honestly, I’m good with both but I really am curious what you can do with a cultivation novel.

Enzo Elacqua

I feel you’re approach to necromancy was super original in Never Die Twice, in that you didn’t make it a black and white thing where it’s misunderstood or a horrible thing. Instead you actually had it be a useful tool, like all magic should be. So I’m gonna have to go with that one. Personally if I’m going to read xianxia it’s gonna have to be a power creep story with exploration as the main component. I feel anything else tends to be done better by more western fantasy since it has less mysticism and a more straightforward approach to town/kingdom building.

Adrian Engel

I just hope that the author will enjoy writing both options equally. I would hate for us to pick the concept he deep down likes less. Can't write a good story if you aren't feeling it imo.

Adrian Engel

I'm torn, I'm really interested to see your take on xianxia. However, I feel that the other concept is more intriguing and inspired. Tough call but I will be voting for #1.

Max Müller

interesting concept but somehow eldtrisch horrors are more intersting, burned too often by xianxia lately

GraySquirrelEatToast

Personally, the niche that this story would fill for me is already taken by Casual Farmer's "Beware of Chicken" so I'll vote for Underland.

Kevin Ramos

I'm all for some kung fu fighting, since we already had a dark fantasy in never die twice

Finn Ryan

Hmm I have got to admit Wuxia/Xianxia feels like a genre that doesn't mix with townbuilding. I have trust in you as an author that you could probably do it, it is just that it feels out of place in the genre. I will go read the other suggestion before making my final decision

Ulbert

Yeah. Really not a Wuxia/Xianxia fan. Sooo…. Yeah. Good concept, still.

Domini

Both? XD whatever you write I will read.

thkiw

Although both are promising, necromancy is barely represented in stories while cultivation without power fantasy kinda ruins the genre/makes it satire. And a city building story has poor prospects in my opinions. The second one is a little more edgy but it develops around forbidden magic, other worlds and souls mages. Just the prospects of other worlds makes it more exciting, If not done badly. I've always wanted a world traveling story. I Think it has good potential.

Deinos

Well I can't say the art and their quality didn't influence my decision, so for me it's 100% Underland.


More Creators