Additional Novel

Anthony Maxwell

No it's not

PerpetualZephyr

This idea is god awful lol.

Felt the same with all 5, which is why I am giving you the tough choice 😅

James French

I’m genuinely tied between 2/3 & 4 😅

Anthony Maxwell

As far as him being able to exit or enter the dungeon whenever. That depends the author could write it so that the main character can't just exit the dungeon whenever as he'd have to go through the various levels. The author could also make it so the main character can only enter the dungeon from various places and not just whenever. If that's the way they want to design how the main characters gamer power works. Also meeting people can still happen through the course of the story.

Anthony Maxwell

Lots of dungeons in fiction have various biomes so he may still have to camp like in the damachi the anime/manga as that's a gamer world dude 😎. It all depends how the author set it up before he could go heavy on the gamer elements or really light. Some of the best gamer stories whether that be from manga or fanfiction go light on the gamer elements but they're still there. As you should look up the author ussexplorer's :(a new player in the force) as he doesn't use a heavy emphasis on the gamer elements but it's still there and it's also an amazing story.

Alba

There is a big difference between a dungeon that you can exit whenever you want like the gamer and real life. Apart from being too convenient you also are skipping all the step of adventuring, spending days in nature while looking for what you want, going away to far away places, meeting new people, the journey of going to those places and everything in between, and more. Dungeon cannot equal the real world; what would be the point otherwise? It just gives the MC an unnecessary op advantage that he could complete by adventuring, which is more interesting.

Some readers might know this, but I don't really like Gamer Fics/Systems, especially if they help too much with something like stores, dungeons, AI, skills, etc. Honestly though, a Pokemon wasn't something I had thought about writing until now, since it's been awhile since I consumed any media of it... I will shelf that idea for now, thanks ^^

Anthony Maxwell

He could search the dungeon for the specific Pokemon he wants completing the exploration part as the dungeon could cover multiple biomes imo. So you didn't really think that one through did you.

Alba

That is not really interesting tho, a dungeon would ruin the point of going out to explore and find pokemon in their biomes. It's more boring imo

Anthony Maxwell

Honestly none of these sound appealing to me. What Does sound appealing to me right now. Would be a Pokemon gamer fanfic where the main character has the power of the gamer and the dungeons the main character would normally enter that are filled with zombies would be filled with pokémon instead he can capture and the character starts with some random starter and a game store where he can buy supplies. In some other universe outside of Pokemon like maybe worm or DC / MCU or possibly Star wars. Why Star wars because I think it'd be kind of funny 🤣 if the main character throughout Pikachu and they had some type of lightning battle with palpatine.