October Recommendations!
🕑 Added 2024-10-01 16:00:19 +0000 UTCHappy October everyone! It's officially spooky season!! I love everything about fall except for horror movies. They're not my thang! Give me some not-so-scary movie recommendations for October! I'm already planning on watching:
Scary Movie
Tucker & Dale v. Evil
Zombieland: Double Tap
Young Frankenstein (as of now, it doesn't look like this one is available to rent or stream in the US, but I'm keeping an eye out for when it becomes available to watch)
I think these movies will give me some comedic relief between the (slightly) scarier movies I'll watch this month. Comment below your recommendations for some horror/thrillers that you think I can handle!
Comments
Major Peril
Here's some of my spooky favorites: - 30 Days of Night (2007) - Let the Right One In (2008) -or- Let Me In (2010) - The Cabin in the Woods (2011) - 28 Days Later (2002) - Werewolf by Night (2022) - The Others (2001) - Fright Night (1985) - Warm Bodies (2013) - Near Dark (1987) - The Lost Boys (1987) - Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1992) - The Conjuring (2013) - Sleepy Hollow (1999) - The Fog (1980) - Pride and Prejudice and Zombies (2016) - World War Z (2013)
Mycenaeus .
The Wicker Man (1973) The Ritual (2017) The Company of Wolves (1982) Valerie and Her Week of Wonders (1970) Pumpkinhead (1988) Viy (1967) Night of the Eagle (1962) The Tingler (1959) The Night of the Hunter (1955) Dark Water (2005) The Golem: How He Came into the World (1920) Dead of Night (1945) The Uninvited (1944) Eye of the Devil (1966) Häxan (1922) The Haunting (1963) Cronos (1992)
Byrd N. Hand
That's why I still prefer physical media whenever possible; streaming services have proven to be too unreliable as far as watching certain movies. 😒
Alex Vazquez
If she faces "Martyrs" head-on, she'll never dread the horror genre again. It's the ultimate antidote to fear!
Fletch
Ghost and Mr Chicken - 1966 Don Knotts Shadow of the Vampire - 2000 Willem Dafoe The Blob - 1958 Steve Mcqueen Death becomes Her - 1992 Meryl Streep, Goldie Hawn
Luis
The Burbs (1989) Practical Magic (1998) Sleepy Hollow (1999) World War Z (Theatrical version) Soul (2020) Men in Black 2&3 (2002/2012) Little Shop of Horrors (1986) High Spirits (1988)
Tim Donnelly
I dried looking for Young Frankenstein but could not find it. I did see that Abbott and Costello meet Frankenstein is on Amazon prime. It’s really old, in B&W, but it’s funny. You might like it.
Patrick Blondin
What? I don’t think Addie will ever forgive you for that suggestion, especially if you mean the original French version. 😅😆
Jacob King
Not Scary Halloween Movies: Happy Death Day The Witches (1990) Coraline A Ghost Story
Sample-Text
Practical Magic (1998)
Mycenaeus .
The Innocents (1961) Corpse Bride (2005) Arsenic and Old Lace (1944) Cat People (1942)
Robert Lemond
Carrie(1976)
Alex Vazquez
You must see "Martyrs". It's an extraordinary horror film that will stay with you forever! "Barbarian" "Alien 3: The Assembly Cut" "Midnight Meat Train" "Ginger Snaps" "Horror Express" "Splinter" "Evil Dead" (2013) "The Blob" (1988) "The Mist" "Deep Red" "The Descent" "Frailty" "Hush" (2016) "What Lies Beneath" "Bram Stoker's Dracula" (1992) "The House by the Cemetery" "Tenebrae" "Run" "Suspiria" (2018) "They" (2002) "The House at the End of the Street" "The Kiss" "Phenomena" "The Devil's Advocate" "The Hunger" "The Vanishing" (1988) "Christine" "Take Shelter"
Rich
Ghost (1990)
Ben
Ah thank you
Byrd N. Hand
She watched "Ghostbusters" as one of her earliest reactions, but removed it from YouTube (along with her reactions to "E.T.," "Beetlejuice," and "Edward Scissorhands"), due to not being satisfied with her editing on it(/them), but unfortunately apparently lost the files containing them before being able to re-edit/re-upload them. 😕
Byrd N. Hand
It seems reactors don't want to watch movies on channels that include ads, despite them still being free... 🤷♂️
Neversure
100% Some people just love to see the world burn....
Neversure
These are all movies that I would call "Friday night movies" In that they are ones that are NOT scary, and don't require much if any thinking. Loaded Weapon 1 Major Payne Hot Shots + the sequel "Killers" (2010) Just Married (2003) The Parent Trap (1998) Kung Pow Enter the Fist A Knights Tale Licence to Wed Shanghai Noon "Red" (2010) + Red 2 (2013) Fools Gold National Treasure 2
Robert Lemond
Night of the Living Dead(1968) The Exorcist(1973) The Texas Chainsaw Massacre(1974) The Omen(1976) American Psycho(2000)
Byrd N. Hand
Granted, it's not the end of the world if she never watches it. There are plenty of other films I want her to react to more than that one. But someone putting so much stock into what other people generally say about a movie before actually seeing it is just plain silly to me. 🤷♂️
Byrd N. Hand
... which itself was a misquote of said line.
David Martin
The Frighteners The Skeleton Key Super 8 Shutter Island 1408
Raj Hudek
-Happy Death Day -Happy Death 2 U -The Others -Trick R Treat
Alex Tan
#DragMeToHellForAddieCounts
Tim Heron
Manhunter is certainly a product of its time, but I think it should be experienced at least once simply because it was the first Hannibal Lecter film; since "Silence of the Lambs" earned so much acclaim, people either don't know or forget that another film predated it.
Pearl Jam
Happy Death Day
Darian Harman
Saturday The 14th (1988) is a wholesome, goofy horror spoof. I think with your theater background, it would be right up your alley.
HeyHeyJK
"Tucker & Dale vs. Evil" and "Cabin in the Woods" are my two favorite horror comedies ever and make a great double-feature.
HeyHeyJK
If you've got a DVD player I can send you the special edition DVD of "Young Frankenstein". Highly doubtful but thought I'd give it a shot since it's my all-time favorite Mel Brooks movie, although you'll get more out of it if you first watch the original "Frankenstein" and "Bride of Frankenstein".
Miles E Coburn
“Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein” (1948)(Black and White) – Comedy duo Bud Abbott and Lou Costello play baggage handlers who run afoul of the Universal Studios monsters. Dracula (Bela Lugosi) wants to use Lou’s brain to re-animate the Frankenstein monster (Glenn Strange) to ensure it is more compliant to his suggestions. Working against Dracula is Lawrence Talbot (aka The Wolfman) who tries to get the two men to aid him in wrecking Dracula’s plans. Also included is a cameo by another of the Universal Studio monsters.
Scot Jebens
I swear half the horror/war movie recommendations have to do less about the movie and more with the ‘Break the cutie’ or ‘Corrupt the cutie’ tropes! :) https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/BreakTheCutie https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CorruptTheCutie
Doug
Drag Me To Hell is great. 👍
Ben
Ghostbusters 1984, the people under the stairs, drag me to hell
Joe Mallard
Exorcist
Thats MR. Baldamort
October Sky!
Chris Bergbower
Deepwater Horizon
Ronny Boss
That movie is great. So many quotable lines
Will Castillo
The Missing (2003 film) It's a spooky, not-so-scary, western film.
Ronny Boss
I second that. It's a hoot and a half
Scott
Army of Darkness
Julian San
All these recommendations are good but I want a movie that will guarantee some tearful bawling. Train to Busan.
Beth Brown
Addie, I worked at Blockbuster for 14 years, so i won't steer u wrong. Here are some horror movies for your Scary but not so Scary Witchtober; 1) Christine 2) Carrie (the original) 3)Constantine 4) The Craft 5) The Lost Boys 6) Bram Stoker's Dracula( Gary oldman) 7) Dracula Dead and Loving it 8) Halloween 2(1981) 8) Talk To Me 9) Beetlejuice 10) Firestarter 11) I Know What You Did Last Summer 12) Trick R' Treat(2007). I love both you, your channel and Ollie. Happy Halloween.
JBK405
"Ready or Not" the the most recent horror movie that really worked for me.
Luis Fernandez
Here are my recommendations for this year: a. Creepshow (1982) or Trick 'r Treat (2007). These are short story compilations. None are too scary, but all entertaining. b. Night of the Living Dead (1968). Classic but still creepy for modern audiences. Like other classic films, it has subtext beyond the obvious story. c. An American Werewolf in London (1981). Classic. A good mixture of horror and humor, but I would call it a horror and not a horror-comedy. Not too scary but brilliant. d. Talk To Me (2022). Goriest and creepiest I'll suggest. If you like horror it isn't scary, but if you scare easy it'll be enough to make you uncomfortable. e. The Witch (2015). Probably my favorite horror movie from the last 25 years. Some people find it boring but I think it is a slow burn that is creepy as hell. (And I fully support the "no Exorcist" decision... but if you do change your mind I vote for the original version)
Happy Hanukkah
Army of Darkness (1992). [I'm firmly in the "stand-alone" camp.]
Happy Hanukkah
No, he was accurately spoofing the spoof of the line from Blazing Saddles. Quite fitting, given the director/writer. :-)
Mr. Writhms
Byrd: I come here to enjoy myself, not to petty squabble over movies. I'm just going by what Addie expressed to us. "The Exorcist" is not scary at all to me anymore; it was when I was a kid. But what is not scary to us may scare others. That's all I'm saying. You can continue your crusade to convince Addie to watch whatever you want. I won't interject with your posts any further. No hard feelings from my end.
Byrd N. Hand
So, basically, you're not even remotely interested in challenging someone's preconceived notions about something...
Mr. Writhms
Byrd: 👏
Mr. Writhms
It boils down to this for me: I'm a horror fan but if someone relays to me they don't want to watch a movie for whatever reason, I don't try to pressure them. People have boundaries and I respect them. That's it.
Byrd N. Hand
Well, Mr. Writhms, you just attempted to spoof one of the most commonly misquoted lines from a movie ever, alongside 'Play it again, Sam' and 'Luke, I am your father:' 'Badges? We ain't got no badges. We don't need no badges. I don't have to show you any stinkin' badges!' from "The Treasure of the Sierra Madre."
thomas king
October is also known as Rock-tober. Movies about bands to break up the horror and blood. This is Spinal Tap, The Commitments, Jersey Boys, Straight Out of Compton, La Bamba, Detroit Rock City......
Mr. Writhms
Byrd: Half the fun to me is watching the movie along with the reactor. Plus I laugh every time I watch "Young Frankenstein". If that is an offense then I gladly hand you my credentials. 😏 "Credentials?! We don't need no stinking credentials!" (If you can name the movie I just spoofed with that quote, you win.)
Jay Perry
I am using a Roku TV and in the Movieland Tv channel, I can watch Young Frankenstein free. I'm in America. Maybe that's a solution?
Byrd N. Hand
Yet sadness/depression can potentially make people want to off themselves, Mr. Writhms... 🤐
drew
i would recomend ghostbusters (1984) hocus pocus (1993) casper fright night (1985)
Jay Perry
Your lineup is perfect for me. No notes.
Pendragon1951
I would like to recommend The Uninvited 1944, It's a classic black and white, it's a little scary, has mystery, comedy romance and even a dog! It's the perfect October movie if you need a link let me know.
Byrd N. Hand
If you truly think "The Exorcist" is any scarier than "The Shining," you're delusional. This idea that she can't handle the former after handling the latter is just ridiculous, IMO.
Mr. Writhms
Byrd: Because fear is the only emotion that makes you shit your pants. :)
Kyle Brandon Sanger
Totally agree. I'm not a fan of horror myself, but over the last few years, I've watch a lot more horror than I'd my entire life, some were better than others. Horror as a genre doesn't get the respect it deserves. For example, the Academy only recognized 'Silence of the Lambs' because it was labeled as psychological thriller NOT horror. The word horror is 'sensitive' when it comes to the Academy. My guess is that horror is made for the cheap and not the usual multi-million summer blockbuster like the rest of the Hollywood genres, also, horror is varied with possession, monster/creature feature, serial killer/thriller, ghosts, and found footage.
BareJordan
I'd like to recommend Happy Death Day (2017). It's a horror comedy and a very fun one at that. You can handle the spooky parts.
max
Bubba Ho tep. Funny and just a little scary
Andre Agog
I would recommend Peter Jackson's first two movies: Bad Taste (1987) and Meet The Feebles (1989). It will show you a very different side of the man who went onto direct Lord of the Rings!
Travis Berzas
Hey, I'm not sure whether you use streaming stuff exclusively, for which this one may not be available, but the WNUF Halloween Special is not very scary and is a good Halloween movie. It's a mockumentary kind of thing, replicating local TV Halloween programming from the '80s.
Mr. Writhms
Byrd: MY apologies. I'm sure "WE WANT THE EXORCIST" was working. lol
ButtercupsTrueLove
"Invasion of the Body Snatchers", the 1978 remake, shot on location in San Francisco. "World War Z" (2013). More action thriller than gore fest.
Byrd N. Hand
I'd love to see her finish the Hannibal Lecter series by watching both "Red Dragon" and "Hannibal." She can skip the universally despised "Hannibal Rising." "Manhunter" did nothing for me when I first saw it (it almost felt a bit like a glorified Miami Vice episode to me... and the less said about the cheesy-ass synth score, the better), but if she wants to watch it somewhere down the road, so be it.
SavageDiplomat
Since you are doing Scary Movie which is a spoof of horror films id recommend you watch I Know what you did "last summer" before watching Scary Movie since its one of the main spoofs along with Scream
Byrd N. Hand
Mr. Writhms, if you claim to be a film buff but still don't know most of the story beats to "Young Frankenstein" without having to actually literally see them in front of your face, I'd say you might want to have your credentials revoked. 🤐
Byrd N. Hand
I'm personally sick of this double standard so many people have toward horror films compared to all other genres. Why is fear so much harder for people to willingly expose themselves to than any other emotion?? 🤷♂️🤷♂️
Tim Heron
Manhunter (1986) and/or Red Dragon (2002). Not scary, per se, but good thrillers. Edit: I'd also add the original 1973 version of "The Wicker Man".
Byrd N. Hand
Mr, Writhms, you're not exactly helping our cause. Stop discouraging her from watching cinematic classics.
RX-1
War of the Worlds (2005) Shutter (2004) Let Me In (2010) Silent Hill (2006)
Mr. Writhms
Byrd, please send us all a copy of the movie. Thanks! 😁
Ian Forbes
Monster Squad (1987) will be right up your alley.
Kyle Brandon Sanger
I think 'The Shining' is childsplay, its not scary at all. Along with 'The Exorcist' they're what I personally call horror epics, grand in the vain of historical epics but with horror. Also, I have recommended 'The Evil Dead' trilogy to Addie before. She knows that they are more or less horror comedies but I've recommended she should start with 'Evil Dead 2' because its more a comedy and less gore. 'Ash vs Evil Dead' is an underrated series and I was sad that it got cancelled.
Byrd N. Hand
She's seen all of those except "Coraline," "Sleepy Hollow," "Hotel Transylvania," and "The Omen."
Andy Munden
Coraline Nightmare Before Christmas Sleepy Hollow (1999) Alien Ghostbusters (1984) Hocus Pocus Hotel Transylvania The Omen (1976)
Mr. Writhms
She will watch it only with the sound off and blurred.
Philip Davetas
RETURN OF THE LIVING DEAD, damn it.
Byrd N. Hand
Forgive me for having the foresight to see that this whole streaming situation was going to be a total clusterfuck for being able to watch certain titles. 🤷♂️ Either way, I know the movie well enough that I don't really need to literally watch it along with her to get the full effect of her reaction (as I have with several other titles). I'd like to think a fair amount of others feel the same way.
Byrd N. Hand
Yes, I believe the scariness of "The Exorcist" has been greatly exaggerated over the years. If she survived "The Shining," she can survive that one. And if you're going to recommend the "Evil Dead" movies, you might as well have her start with the first one.
Mr. Writhms
I second "Sleepy Hollow", a great Tim Burton movie. She's not going near "The Exorcist" with a 10 foot cross. lol
JDV
Hellboy (2004) is more fantasy gothic but is spooky sometimes, and it seems other reactors are doing this movie lately because of the new one that came out. It's fun and funny and not very scary.
Doug
Only problem is even if Addie has the DvD the great majority of her Patreon audience won’t. Hardly anybody will be able to watch along.
Joseph Blankenship
I'm not a big horror person either, but I've come to really love the Scream franchise recently. So, if you could do Scream 2, that would be great. Only other one I could think as a horror comedy that would be nice is 'The Blackening'.
Mr. Writhms
Here's few to choose from: "Braindead" (1992, horror/comedy: zombies, very over the top exaggerated gore meant for laughs). "The Birds" (1963, Alfred Hitchcock: killer birds, suspenseful). "Monster House" (2006, animated horror/comedy). "Blade 2: (2002, action/horror: Blade battling creepy monster vampires this time). "The Frighteners" (1996, horror/comedy: Michael J. Fox plays a ghost hunter). "Identity" (2003, horror/mystery: a very good suspense thriller whodunit with John Cusack). "Creepshow" (1982, horror/fantasy: 5 short stories based on a horror comic book. Purposely campy to mimic the comic book, some gore, and a few jump scares. "Happy Death Day" (2017, horror/mystery: Think a cross between "Groundhog Day" and "Scream", a LOT of fun.
Byrd N. Hand
If it seems you can't access "Young Frankenstein" before the end of the month, I'll personally gift you either a DVD or Blu-ray copy (with all my credit card rewards points, I won't have to actually pay anything for it). Just PM me which format you'd prefer and the address to which I should send it. This is why I feel physical media should still be considered relevant.
Byrd N. Hand
I'd prefer she watch the original "Night of the Living Dead" before "Dawn of the Dead."
DM DC
Tucker and Dale vs Evil is great!!!! That has my vote 100%!
Thomas Wetherell
Super 8 (2011).
Byrd N. Hand
Indeed, Shyamalan lost me with "Signs"... though most didn't start catching on to his one-trick pony hack-ery until either "The Village" or "Lady in the Water"... or "The Happening"... or "The Last Airbender" if you were *really* dim. 🤷♂️
Kyle Brandon Sanger
Me: cracks knuckles. Train to Busan. The Evil Dead 2 Army of Darkness Dog Soldiers Night of the Living Dead (1968) Return of the Living Dead (1985) 28 Days Later 28 Weeks Later (Has one of my favorites scenes ever!!) 30 Days of Night Interview with the Vampire (film) Blair Witch Project (1999) The Exorcist (1973) [It's really not that scary IMO] Near Dark [Better than 'The Lost Boys'] Constantine (2005) [Its a DC/Vertigo comic book film] Bram Stoker's Dracula (1992) Event Horizon Sleepy Hollow (1999) Insidious Trick r Treat Creep Show (1982) Fright Night
Brent Petty
Train to Busan
carbsix
Misery... yes!
Byrd N. Hand
Of course, "The 'Burbs" also includes a brief, spoiler-ish clip of another major horror movie, so I'd rather she not watch it until she's watched that one first (no matter how much she may protest 🤐).
Doug
That movie is hilarious! 😄
Ernesto Lopez
Scary stories to tell in the dark
Cameron Kerby
Right on dude. The Burbs is awesome.
Steve
The Evil Dead (1981) Misery (1990) Event Horizon (1997) Train to Busan (2016) A Quiet Place (2018)
Doug
Whoa, that’s a deep cut! 😄 Michael J Fox horror movie, not a log of people have seen it either. I thought it was fun though. 👍
Ronny Boss
A good horror comedy you would probably enjoy is Behind the Mask:The Rise of Leslie Vernon. It's a pretty smart take on the slasher genre
Doug
Long list! Out of these, my favorites are Witches of Eastwick, Misery, 28 Days Later, An American Werewolf in London, The Exorcist, and The Omen
Alex Tan
Say it with me: WE WANT THE EXORCIST! ✊✊✊✊ WE WANT THE EXORCIST! ✊✊✊✊ WE WANT THE EXORCIST! ✊✊✊✊ WE WANT THE EXORCIST! ✊✊✊✊ #TheExorcistForAddieCounts
Nathan Swapp
Sleepy Hollow (1999) And a lighter toned underrated movie, The House with a clock in its walls (with Jack Black & Cate Blanchett)
Doug
It Follows is a solid movie. 👍
Doug
I almost put Wicker Man on my list too. Just make sure it’s the original, the remake with Nicholas Cage is awful!
Thats MR. Baldamort
I will also request Cloverfield! I will also suggest getting into the mosterverse with Godzilla 2014!
Doug
I don’t like Signs personally, but The Mist is a good one. 🙂
Doug
Ooh, Cloverfield and Don’t Breathe are both great. 👍
Wolverine
Hereditary, Hellraiser, Midsommar, Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Dawn of the Dead (1978), Reanimator
Cameron Kerby
Fantastic suggestion. I love that movie.
Doug
As far as more serious, scarier horror movies go, my suggestions include - Let the Right One In - An American Werewolf in London (it’s half comedy, half scary) - 28 Days Later (my favorite zombie movie after Shaun of the Dead) - Get Out - Midsommar or Hereditary (both really good but also really intense, fyi) - The Babadook (🎵 doo-dooo da doo-dooo) - The Omen or The Exorcist (Not sure Addie will watch these but they’re classics so I wouldn’t feel right not including them)
Byrd N. Hand
Nothing 'horror' about "Murder by Death;" it's basically an Agatha Christie/whodunnit spoof. If she watches "Little Shop of Horrors," I recommend she watches either the theatrical cut or director's cut in its entirety and then also watches the just third act of whichever version she didn't watch as well (since that last act is literally the only difference between the 2 versions).
Randee Carreno
Happy October Tuesday, Addie! 🎃👻 Here are some of my favorite scary movies: "Night of the Comet"(1984)- a campy zombie movie, at least the first "Scream" movie(1996), the original 1984 "A Nightmare on Elm Street"(it's always a must-watch for me this time of the year), "The Exorcist"(1973), the original 1982 "Poltergeist", "The Burbs"(1989), "Clue(1985)- a fun type of spooky movie, the 1990 2-part "IT" mini-series, the 2017 "IT" remake and the 2019 sequel "IT: Chapter 2", "Lights Out"(2016), and because of the sequel movie that's in theaters now, if you haven't seen yet "Beetlejuice"(1988). Have a great day today! 😊
Doug
Tucker and Dale and Young Frankenstein are awesome. 😄 Unfortunately, like you said, Young Frankenstein seems to be totally unavailable on any streaming service and has been for a few years. Disney apparently owns the rights to it but for some reason they’re sitting on it with no sign of putting it up on Disney+ or anywhere else, it’s very strange considering how popular the movie is.
Byrd N. Hand
I don't really think this is a specific October-only title.
Simon Haynes
Cloverfield (2008) Crawl (2019) Don't Breathe (2016) The Faculty (1998) Happy Death Day (2017) Lake Placid (1999)
Mathias
Some you could probably handle: The Mist (2007) Signs (2002) Legion (2010) The Wolfman (2010) There's a newer, more intense movie I think many of us would like you to see called Last Voyage of the Demeter.
Jon Anderson
I'll go for a couple of British classics. I think you might like The Wicker Man (1973), it's more mystery/suspense than horror and will keep you guessing. If you're in the mood for a horror comedy, Theatre of Blood (1973) is a hoot.
John W Foster
You might also consider the Burbs (1989), if you haven't seen it. It has both Tom Hanks and Carrie Fisher and is a sort of lighter, comedic horror movie. A slightly scarier movie (thought it's animated, so your mileage may vary) is Coraline (2009).
Ben Wheeler
Ok some of these are admittedly pretty old school and I mentioned some in the comments for Van Helsing but Frankenstein (1931), Bride of Frankenstein (1935), The Mummy (1932), Abbot and Costello Meet Frankenstein (1948), The Ghost and Mr Chicken (Don Knotts, 1966), The Halloween Tree (1993), Sleepy Hollow (1999), It Follows (2014) .
stray
What We Do in the Shadows (2014)
Justin
Seeing as you liked the first one, I will recommend continuing the Scream franchise with Scream 2. The also Tim Burton's Sleepy Hollow featuring Johnny Depp, The Frighteners featuring Michael J Fox, and Ernest Scared Stupid for some lighthearted dumb scaryness.
OldManVax
I completely agree that the Addams Family movies are super seasonally appropriate and a lot of fun.
SnakeandNape
Duel, Stephen Speilberg's first movie as a director. It's more of a thriller but not too scary.
Patrick Blondin
Nimona (2023) ❤️
KingGoji94
More recently horror, late night with the devil is a good one too I think you can handle
Alex Tan
Happy Tuesday and Happy October, Addie. For the scaries, my recommendations are Rosemary's Baby (1968), The Exorcist (1973), Cape Fear (both 1962 & 1991 versions), Copycat (1995), Fear (1996), Anaconda (1997), Scream 2 (1997), Hollow Man (2000), What Lies Beneath (2000), *EDIT 2: Hide and Seek (2005)*, The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor (2008), Nope (2022), Smile (2022), *EDIT 3: Trap (2024)*, the Evil Dead trilogy and Evil Dead Rise (2023). For the fun stuff, I suggest Freaky (2020), the Ghostbusters sequels Ghostbusters II (1989), Ghostbusters: Afterlife (2021), & Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire (2024), The Haunted Mansion (2003), Haunted Mansion (2023), Casper (1995), *EDIT: Hubie Halloween (2020)*, and Totally Killer (2023). #MoreHalloweenMoviesForAddieCounts
carbsix
Pumpkinhead (1988)
Emptysea93
Another spooky but not scary set of movies is the 90s Addams Family movies with Raul Julia, Angelica Houston, and Christina Ricci. If you have not already seen them, they are an absolute blast and cult classic. Given your love of some other random stuff on here I think they will be good for you.
Byrd N. Hand
I already gave you this list back in your 'Ask Me Anything' segment for August, but I'll just post it again (with a couple additions): More comedic/light-hearted in nature: "Murder by Death" "Clue" "The Witches of Eastwick" "The 'Burbs" "Corpse Bride" "Dark Shadows" "Frankenweenie" "What We Do in the Shadows" Sequels/prequels to past October reactions: "Red Dragon" and "Hannibal" "Prometheus" "Doctor Sleep" 'Creature' features: "Creature from the Black Lagoon" "The Birds" "Piranha" (1978) "Invasion of the Body Snatchers" (1978) "Arachnophobia" More 'thriller-y' than scary: "Repulsion" "Wait Until Dark" "Rosemary's Baby" "Play 'Misty' for Me" "The Dead Zone" "Christine" "Misery" "Black Swan" More tragic than scary: "Frankenstein" (1931) [you'll get even more of the jokes in "Young Frankenstein" if you watch this first] "The Fly" (1986) Zombie movies (not as comedic in nature as "Shaun of the Dead" or "Zombieland"): "Night of the Living Dead" (1968) and "Dawn of the Dead" (1978) "28 Days Later" "Train to Busan" Werewolf movies: "The Wolf Man" (1941) "The Howling" "An American Werewolf in London" Bona fide horror films: "The Exorcist" (many of us are just going to keep persisting on this one 🤐) "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" (1974) "Black Christmas" (1974) [you can also watch this in December 😏] "The Omen" (1976) "Suspiria" (1977) "The Fog" (1980) "Poltergeist" (1982) "Sleepy Hollow"
Joe Cross
The Little Stranger has a creepy factor but isn’t scary. Murder By Death is a comedy / horror. And of course Little Shop of Horrors the musical comedy is always a banger
carbsix
The Others (2001)
BNJ
The Frighteners (1996) Sleepy Hollow (1999) Addams Family (1991) - not exactly horror but quite "halloweeney"
David Crabtree
Scream 2 (1997)
Carlo Glingani
Ready Or Not (2019)
Ali D
The Frighteners
Chase
9 (2009)
Billy Dancel
The Corpse Bride
carbsix
Fallen (1998)
Cole Trahan
Hours (2013) not too scary but it’s a thriller, based on a real event.
KingGoji94
The omen (1976) I think you can handle that one
Cameron Kerby
Stir of Echoes (Kevin Bacon) The Burbs (Tom Hanks)