WickedWare
patreon
E3 Survey Review - Part 15
🕑 Added 2025-01-23 20:12:07 +0000 UTCLast couple of questions before Q&A.
Many AVN's sort their replays by each girl. The main reason I haven't done that is because there are so many girls in Elmwood and most only have a scene or two max. But here's what you said:
The 43.7 red category are those of you wanting it sorted into folders of each girl. So not a majority. Maybe this will change when there are more replay scenes but for now it seems you don't want this change and I agree.
I am very confused though by the multiple comments asking for the replay scenes to be sorted in order. They are in order. They are in exact chronological order, by each episode and within each episode, so I'm not sure what some of you mean by that. Maybe you mean that they should be labelled as "E1 scenes", "E2 scenes" or something like that.
So I'll probably ask this question again in a few episodes time but for now I won't be making any changes.
The last question before the Q&A is a fun one to end on and that's your favourite perks:
Your favourite perk is.... Cum Drunk! Which beats the other two tier 3 cum perks even though creampies were voted as the favourite finishing option in a previous question. But I'm really glad you like cum drunk so much - it does require me to make a few extra renders for most scenes but I've always thought it was worth it and clearly it is. Let's see the other top perks:
1. Cum Drunk
2. Dexterity
3. Joint Orgasm
4. G-Spot Penetration
5. Oral Mastery
So overall a very strong performance from the Orgasmic tree. Remember that perks you can't have unlocked yet (like Devil's Kiss) aren't listed here. The lowest scoring perk is Nocturnal, and I have seen a lot of valid criticism of the Nocturnal tree which I largely agree with. But instead of making any changes to Nocturnal, I'll be looking to have more scenarios which value Dark Temptation and Blind Lust in future eps.
Did any perks surprise you with their results? Think a perk is super underrated? Feel free to share your thoughts!
Comments
Liam Edwards
Having a recap of everything that has happened at the start of an episode is something I've wanted from other AVNs. If Saki did this in their own way for Elmwood, that would be amazing.
PickerPatron
Will Saki explain to us in E4 where these strange powers/perks come from? I mean her theory ππ. The others have no idea, but Saki investigates everything π.
Liam Edwards
Just an idea on this. In group settings, you can make it so flexing your muscles impresses one (or more) girl, while another dislikes it. It becomes a trade off, you can really impress some girls while losing love with another.
Liam Edwards
I've seen a few games structure their replays like it, Eternum being one of them. Eternum takes it a step further by having "shortcuts" to the girl-specific filters by having buttons for each of the main girls. While that would be nice, it could be a bit much with the 18 in Elmwood.
GuySmiley
Agree that it would be nice to see some scenes that have payoffs for people who have started to put points in the Light or Dark trees. Maybe in an upcoming episode there could be a scene that's only available to those who have the Benevolence trait and another scene that's only available to those who have the Dark Temptation perk (for example). I'm sure there will be some who have saves for both paths, but it might be a nice feature (or maybe a difficult choice!) for those who want to commit to one or the other.
U.
The replay in Eternum does exactly that, so if you look at its code you'll find everything already there. I made the replay for another game using it as a base in the past so feel free to ask me any question if needed.
Ichigo Kurosaki
Yeah, but that suggests that intellectual women don't like fit people at all. So if that was implemented I wouldn't make it that way for everyone and maybe put in their bio's something like "(character name) is interested in intelligence over appearances."
Liam Edwards
You get +10 in total from Joint Orgasm. +4 from Warm Cum, +4 from Soothing Cum, and +2 from Joint Orgasm. While you do get the bonuses twice for Cum Drunk, Joint Orgasm still gives more. The tallies are +10 from Joint Orgasm, +8 from Cum Drunk, and +6 from Cum Selfie (with some Lust of their friends).
danielwpeer
Cum Drunk is the highest potential scoring finisher. the +4 is really +8 because you do it twice (Feed her!) and you get multiple opportunities to make her orgasm. And, it works for most scenes, especially in the first episode. There is only a couple of scenes that don't have swallowing as an option.
Liam Edwards
I think the reason why Cum Drunk is rated so high is because the equivalent skills for the other endings are kind of lacking. Cum Selfie is amusing but has very little content added to it, which I think most people would rather. The love and lust bonuses are just that, bonuses. Unless things start requiring large amounts of love in the future, I don't think those bonuses will be that necessary. Joint Orgasm is probably the worst of the three. You make them orgasm which yields +2 love, but you're already getting +8 from Soothing Cum. It also leads to the Potent Cum skill which unless you're interested in pregnancy content, you probably don't want to take. The Joint Orgasm skill, in my honest opinion, should have its benefits reconsidered. Just a wild idea: Add an additional skill between Potent Cum and Cum Addiction (the space is there) that requires both of them. When active, you can get the benefits (where applicable) from all three trees regardless of the ending you choose.
WickedWare
Liam, I think this is a 10/10 suggestion for when there are more scenes. I really really love this idea and I'm very keen on introducing something like this in the medium term future when there are a bit more scenes to sift through. Thanks for this awesome suggestion!
Liam Edwards
With replays, one idea would be to keep the current display but have two filters at the top, one for the girl and another for action. So if you wanted to filter the list to just Chelsea's scenes, you can. If you only want scenes containing anal, you can do that with the action filter. If you only want Chelsea's anal scenes, use both. Could even go a step further and add a filter for the episode, but I think that's largely overkill and not really necessary.
WickedWare
This is a really interesting idea. My only hesitation is that I want perks to always feel rewarding but this is a cool suggestion
Dr.Berilio
I think it would be nice if perks like scholar, ripped, etc would give you option on conversations or actions that actually arenβt good. Like flexing muscles on a smart girl isnβt a wise moveβ¦
